Chinese report documents human rights disaster in the United States
by Patrick Martin
wsws.org (March 19 2010)
World Socialist Web Site
Published by the International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI)
On March 13, China's Information Office of the State Council published a report titled, "The Human Rights Record of the United States in 2009".
This document was clearly intended as a rebuttal to the annual US State Department Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2009, released two days earlier.
The Chinese report quite legitimately notes that the US government "releases Country Reports on Human Rights Practices year after year to accuse other countries, and takes human rights as a political instrument to interfere in other countries' internal affairs, defame other nations' image and seek its own strategic interests. This fully exposes its double standards on the human rights issue ..."
Delivering the US government a well-deserved dose of its own medicine does not, of course, absolve the Chinese regime of its own gross violations of human rights. It rules autocratically over 1.3 billion people, most of them desperately poor peasants and super-exploited workers.
That being said, the Chinese report is an eye-opening document - factual, sober, even understated, drawn entirely from public government and media sources in the United States, with each item carefully documented. It presents a picture of 21st century America as much of the world sees it, one which is in sharp contrast to the official mythology and American media propaganda.
Not surprisingly, the report went unmentioned in the US mass media.
The fourteen-page report is divided into six major sections: Life, Property and Personal Security; Civil and Political Rights; Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; Racial Discrimination; Rights of Women and Children; US Violations of Human Rights Against Other Nations. The cumulative picture is one of a society in deep and worsening social crisis.
A few of the facts and figures cited on violence and police repression in the United States:
* Each year, 30,000 people die in gun-related incidents.
* There were 14,180 murders last year.
* In the first ten months of 2009, 45 people were killed by police use of tasers, bringing the total for the decade to 389.
* Last year, 315 police officers in New York City were subject to internal supervision due to "unrestrained use of violence".
* 7.3 million Americans were under the authority of the correctional system, more than in any other country.
* An estimated 60,000 prisoners were raped while in custody last year.
On democratic rights, the report notes the pervasive government spying on citizens, authorized under the 2001 Patriot Act, extensive surveillance of the Internet by the National Security Agency, and police harassment of anti-globalization demonstrators in Pittsburgh during last year's G-20 summit. Pointing to the hypocrisy of US government "human rights" rhetoric, the authors observe, "the same conduct in other countries would be called human rights violations, whereas in the United States it was called necessary crime control".
The report only skims the surface on the socioeconomic crisis in the United States, noting record levels of unemployment, poverty, hunger and homelessness, as well as 46.3 million people without health insurance. It does offer a few facts rarely discussed in the US media:
* 712 bodies were cremated at public expense in the city of Los Angeles last year, because the families were too poor to pay for a burial.
* There were 5,657 workplace deaths recorded in 2007, the last year for which a tally is available, a rate of seventeen deaths per day (not a single employer was criminally charged for any of these deaths).
* Some 2,266 veterans died as a consequence of lack of health insurance in 2008, fourteen times the military death toll in Afghanistan that year.
The report presents evidence of pervasive racial discrimination against blacks, Hispanics and Native Americans, the most oppressed sections of the US working class, including a record number of racial discrimination claims over hiring practices, more than 32,000. It also notes the rising number of incidents of discrimination or violence against Muslims, and the detention of 300,000 "illegal" immigrants each year, with more than 30,000 immigrants in US detention facilities every day of the year.
It notes that the state of California imposed life sentences on eighteen times more black defendants than white, and that in 2008, when New York City police fired their weapons, 75 percent of the targets were black, 22 percent Hispanic and only three percent white.
The report refers to the well-known reality of unequal pay for women, with median female income only 77 percent that of male income in 2008, down from 78 percent in 2007. According to the report, seventy percent of working-age women have no health insurance, or inadequate coverage, high medical bills or high health-related debt.
Children bear a disproportionate burden of economic hardship, with 16.7 million children not having enough food at some time during 2008, and 3.5 million children under five facing hunger or malnutrition, seventeen percent of the total. Child hunger is combined with the malignant phenomenon of rampant child labor in agriculture: some 400,000 child farm workers pick America's crops. The US also leads the world in imprisoning children and juveniles, and is the only country that does not offer parole to juvenile offenders.
US foreign policy comes in for justifiable criticism as well. A country with so many poor and hungry people accounts for 42 percent of the world's total military spending, a colossal $607 billion, as well as the world's largest foreign arms sales, $37.8 billion in 2008, up nearly fifty percent from the previous year.
The Chinese report notes the documented torture of prisoners in Afghanistan, Iraq and Guantanamo Bay, the worldwide US network of military bases, the US blockade of Cuba (opposed by the UN General Assembly by a vote of 187 to 3), and the systematic US spying around the world, utilizing the NSA's "ECHELON" interception system, as well as the US monopoly control over Internet route servers.
The report also points out the deliberate US flouting of international human rights covenants. Washington has either signed but not ratified or refused to sign four major UN covenants: on economic, social and cultural rights; on the rights of women; on the rights of people with disabilities; and on the rights of indigenous peoples.
The report does not discuss the source of the malignant social conditions in the United States - nor should that be expected, since that would require an explanation of the causal connection between poverty, repression and discrimination and the operations of the capitalist profit system, something that Beijing is hardly likely to undertake.
Copyright (c) 1998-2010 World Socialist Web Site - All rights reserved
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2010/mar2010/pers-m19.shtml
Bill Totten http://www.ashisuto.co.jp/english/index.html
wsws.org (March 19 2010)
World Socialist Web Site
Published by the International Committee of the Fourth International (ICFI)
On March 13, China's Information Office of the State Council published a report titled, "The Human Rights Record of the United States in 2009".
This document was clearly intended as a rebuttal to the annual US State Department Country Reports on Human Rights Practices for 2009, released two days earlier.
The Chinese report quite legitimately notes that the US government "releases Country Reports on Human Rights Practices year after year to accuse other countries, and takes human rights as a political instrument to interfere in other countries' internal affairs, defame other nations' image and seek its own strategic interests. This fully exposes its double standards on the human rights issue ..."
Delivering the US government a well-deserved dose of its own medicine does not, of course, absolve the Chinese regime of its own gross violations of human rights. It rules autocratically over 1.3 billion people, most of them desperately poor peasants and super-exploited workers.
That being said, the Chinese report is an eye-opening document - factual, sober, even understated, drawn entirely from public government and media sources in the United States, with each item carefully documented. It presents a picture of 21st century America as much of the world sees it, one which is in sharp contrast to the official mythology and American media propaganda.
Not surprisingly, the report went unmentioned in the US mass media.
The fourteen-page report is divided into six major sections: Life, Property and Personal Security; Civil and Political Rights; Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; Racial Discrimination; Rights of Women and Children; US Violations of Human Rights Against Other Nations. The cumulative picture is one of a society in deep and worsening social crisis.
A few of the facts and figures cited on violence and police repression in the United States:
* Each year, 30,000 people die in gun-related incidents.
* There were 14,180 murders last year.
* In the first ten months of 2009, 45 people were killed by police use of tasers, bringing the total for the decade to 389.
* Last year, 315 police officers in New York City were subject to internal supervision due to "unrestrained use of violence".
* 7.3 million Americans were under the authority of the correctional system, more than in any other country.
* An estimated 60,000 prisoners were raped while in custody last year.
On democratic rights, the report notes the pervasive government spying on citizens, authorized under the 2001 Patriot Act, extensive surveillance of the Internet by the National Security Agency, and police harassment of anti-globalization demonstrators in Pittsburgh during last year's G-20 summit. Pointing to the hypocrisy of US government "human rights" rhetoric, the authors observe, "the same conduct in other countries would be called human rights violations, whereas in the United States it was called necessary crime control".
The report only skims the surface on the socioeconomic crisis in the United States, noting record levels of unemployment, poverty, hunger and homelessness, as well as 46.3 million people without health insurance. It does offer a few facts rarely discussed in the US media:
* 712 bodies were cremated at public expense in the city of Los Angeles last year, because the families were too poor to pay for a burial.
* There were 5,657 workplace deaths recorded in 2007, the last year for which a tally is available, a rate of seventeen deaths per day (not a single employer was criminally charged for any of these deaths).
* Some 2,266 veterans died as a consequence of lack of health insurance in 2008, fourteen times the military death toll in Afghanistan that year.
The report presents evidence of pervasive racial discrimination against blacks, Hispanics and Native Americans, the most oppressed sections of the US working class, including a record number of racial discrimination claims over hiring practices, more than 32,000. It also notes the rising number of incidents of discrimination or violence against Muslims, and the detention of 300,000 "illegal" immigrants each year, with more than 30,000 immigrants in US detention facilities every day of the year.
It notes that the state of California imposed life sentences on eighteen times more black defendants than white, and that in 2008, when New York City police fired their weapons, 75 percent of the targets were black, 22 percent Hispanic and only three percent white.
The report refers to the well-known reality of unequal pay for women, with median female income only 77 percent that of male income in 2008, down from 78 percent in 2007. According to the report, seventy percent of working-age women have no health insurance, or inadequate coverage, high medical bills or high health-related debt.
Children bear a disproportionate burden of economic hardship, with 16.7 million children not having enough food at some time during 2008, and 3.5 million children under five facing hunger or malnutrition, seventeen percent of the total. Child hunger is combined with the malignant phenomenon of rampant child labor in agriculture: some 400,000 child farm workers pick America's crops. The US also leads the world in imprisoning children and juveniles, and is the only country that does not offer parole to juvenile offenders.
US foreign policy comes in for justifiable criticism as well. A country with so many poor and hungry people accounts for 42 percent of the world's total military spending, a colossal $607 billion, as well as the world's largest foreign arms sales, $37.8 billion in 2008, up nearly fifty percent from the previous year.
The Chinese report notes the documented torture of prisoners in Afghanistan, Iraq and Guantanamo Bay, the worldwide US network of military bases, the US blockade of Cuba (opposed by the UN General Assembly by a vote of 187 to 3), and the systematic US spying around the world, utilizing the NSA's "ECHELON" interception system, as well as the US monopoly control over Internet route servers.
The report also points out the deliberate US flouting of international human rights covenants. Washington has either signed but not ratified or refused to sign four major UN covenants: on economic, social and cultural rights; on the rights of women; on the rights of people with disabilities; and on the rights of indigenous peoples.
The report does not discuss the source of the malignant social conditions in the United States - nor should that be expected, since that would require an explanation of the causal connection between poverty, repression and discrimination and the operations of the capitalist profit system, something that Beijing is hardly likely to undertake.
Copyright (c) 1998-2010 World Socialist Web Site - All rights reserved
http://www.wsws.org/articles/2010/mar2010/pers-m19.shtml
Bill Totten http://www.ashisuto.co.jp/english/index.html
posted by Bill Totten at
8:46 PM
1 Comments:
This is wonderful! How can one get the full document translated into English? suzannedk@gmail.com
By
suzannedk, at 6:39 AM, March 22, 2010
Post a Comment
<< Home